top of page

Vehicle Expenses; The Benefits of Actual Cost and Depreciation

Writer's picture: szogalszogal

Updated: Jan 28

written by: Stephen Zogal, EA


When managing a fleet or utilizing vehicles for business purposes, choosing between deducting actual vehicle costs or using vehicle depreciation can have significant tax and financial implications. Here’s a breakdown of these approaches, their benefits, and considerations for businesses.



A mechanic checking for oil


1. Actual Vehicle Costs

This method allows businesses to deduct all operating expenses associated with a vehicle. These include:


  • Fuel and Oil: Daily expenses for operating the vehicle.

  • Maintenance and Repairs: Costs for keeping the vehicle in working condition.

  • Insurance Premiums: Vehicle-specific insurance policies.

  • Registration Fees and Licenses: Annual or periodic fees for legal compliance.

  • Loan Interest: If the vehicle is financed, the interest portion may be deductible.

  • Parking and Tolls: Business-related costs incurred during travel.


Advantages:

  • Provides a comprehensive reflection of the actual costs incurred during the year.

  • Beneficial for vehicles with high maintenance costs or heavy usage.


Challenges:

  • Requires detailed record-keeping for every expense.

  • May not be as advantageous if actual expenses are relatively low compared to the standard mileage rate (if applicable).



A truck for hauling


2. Vehicle Depreciation

Depreciation allows businesses to spread out the cost of purchasing a vehicle over its useful life. This deduction is calculated using IRS guidelines for depreciation schedules, often employing methods like the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS).

Key factors include:


  • Purchase Price: The initial cost of the vehicle.

  • Useful Life: Typically, vehicles have a five-year depreciation period.

  • Section 179 Deduction: An accelerated depreciation option that allows businesses to deduct the full cost in the year of purchase, up to certain limits.

  • Bonus Depreciation: Additional depreciation allowance under specific conditions.


Advantages:

  • Simplifies deductions by focusing on purchase price and IRS schedules.

  • Encourages large asset purchases by providing substantial deductions early in the asset's life.


Challenges:

  • Does not account for actual usage or operating costs.

  • Deductions reduce significantly after the initial years.


Comparison of Approaches

Criteria

Actual Costs

Depreciation

Flexibility

Varies annually based on usage and expenses.

Fixed schedule over the asset's life.

Complexity

High—requires tracking multiple expenses.

Moderate—requires understanding tax rules.

Initial Benefits

Lower if vehicle is new.

Higher in early years with Section 179.

Long-Term Suitability

Better for vehicles with low depreciation.

Ideal for newer vehicles or long-term use.


Which Should Your Business Choose?

The choice between deducting actual vehicle costs and vehicle depreciation depends on:

  1. Usage Intensity: For high-mileage, older vehicles, actual costs may yield better deductions.

  2. Vehicle Age and Value: Newer vehicles benefit from depreciation-based deductions.

  3. Administrative Capacity: Deducting actual costs requires meticulous record-keeping, while depreciation is simpler once calculated.

  4. Business Cash Flow Needs: Section 179 and bonus depreciation provide immediate cash flow benefits in the year of purchase.


Hybrid Approaches


While most businesses must choose one method for a specific vehicle, reevaluating the strategy annually for new vehicle acquisitions can maximize tax benefits.

Choosing between actual vehicle costs and depreciation isn’t just a tax decision; it impacts cash flow, financial reporting, and operational budgeting. Businesses should work closely with financial advisors or tax professionals to ensure they make the most cost-effective and compliant decision.


If you need extra help in deciding what is right for you, visit us and schedule a consultation with our team!



19 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page